Cleaning products are a heavily marketed category and environmental claims are largely unregulated in their wording. The Competition and Markets Authority has published a Green Claims Code setting out what businesses should do, and in practice a great deal of packaging still relies on impressions rather than evidence.
What are the warning signs?
- Vague words with no definition – natural, pure, gentle, kind to the planet, green.
- A claim with no scope – recyclable, without saying which part or where.
- Irrelevant claims – phosphate free on a product that never contained them.
- Green visual cues – leaves, earth tones and kraft paper with no substance behind them.
- One good attribute highlighted while the rest is unchanged.
- Self created logos that look like certifications.
What does natural mean on a label?
Nothing specific. There is no agreed definition for cleaning products, and it carries no implication about safety or environmental impact.
Plenty of naturally occurring substances are hazardous, and plenty of synthetic ones are benign and break down readily. The word tells you about marketing rather than about the product.
What about plant based?
More specific and still incomplete. It indicates the origin of some ingredients without saying which ones, what proportion, or what the environmental cost of producing them was.
A product listing plant derived surfactants is telling you more than one simply labelled plant based, which may describe a single minor ingredient.
What about recyclable packaging?
Worth reading closely. Recyclable in principle is not the same as recycled in practice, and it varies by local authority. A bottle may be recyclable while its trigger spray, pump or label is not.
Look for a stated recycled content, which is a measurable claim, and check whether the trigger can be reused or returned rather than binned.
What is a genuinely good sign?
- A recognised third party certification with an identifiable scheme behind it.
- A full ingredients list rather than a selective one.
- A specific, measurable claim with a figure attached.
- A refill or concentrate format, which is a structural change rather than a message.
- Transparency about what the product is not, which suggests confidence.
What about free from claims?
Often technically true and strategically misleading. Free from a substance that was never used in that category, or that has been banned for years, implies a problem in competing products that does not exist.
Phosphate free on a domestic detergent is the clearest example, since phosphates are already restricted.
How do you check a certification?
Look it up. A genuine scheme has a website, published criteria and a searchable register of certified products. A logo that leads nowhere is a marketing device.
Be aware that some legitimate certifications cover a narrow aspect, such as animal testing or packaging, rather than overall environmental impact.
What should you do about it?
Judge the format before the formulation. A concentrate in a small bottle, a refill sachet or a solid tablet represents a real reduction in water, weight and packaging regardless of what the ingredients list says.
After that, look for a certification, then read the ingredients. The front of the bottle is the least informative part of it.
What is the most reliable signal of all?
Buying less. A household with six products it uses regularly has a smaller impact than one with twenty, whatever those twenty are labelled. No marketing claim competes with not buying something.
Is greenwashing always deliberate?
Not necessarily. Some claims are vague because the underlying science is genuinely complicated, and some companies make honest improvements and describe them badly. The effect on a shopper is the same either way, which is why looking for specific evidence rather than judging intent is the more useful approach.
What is the CMA Green Claims Code?
Guidance published by the Competition and Markets Authority setting out what businesses should do when making environmental claims: be truthful, be clear, not omit important information, and be able to substantiate what they say. It applies to businesses rather than being a label you can look for, and it gives a reasonable basis for scepticism about claims that meet none of those tests.